The Best Smelling Shave Soap (Our 5 Favorite Scents)

For the average guy, a shaving routine likely consists of a razor and shaving cream. This setup is typical for most men, and while there isn’t anything inherently wrong with it, you can truly elevate your shave game by switching out your basic cream for a best smelling shave soap.

In addition to usually having a much better scent than cream and gel, shave soap is an all-around more premium option to lubricate your face before you start shaving. It’s certainly an older way of doing things, but it’s also the preferred method for any guy that’s tried it out before.

There are tons of shave soap scents, brands, and styles to choose from, and if you don’t know much about the world of shaving soap, this guide will help break down everything you need to know about the 5 best options that are currently on the market.

So, if you’re ready to start treating your face and facial hair to the shaving experience they deserve, keep on reading.

1. Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap with Shea Butter

The very first shave soap that we’d like to talk about is Henry Cavendish’s Himalaya Shaving Soap with Shave Butter. This soap is made solely in the United States, and it does a fantastic job at creating an ultra-thick lather that lubricates your razor for a super-smooth shaving experience every time you call upon it.


You won’t find Shea Butter in every shaving soap on this list, but we absolutely love its presence in Henry Cavendish’s product. The butter does a fantastic job at moisturizing your skin and keeping it super smooth all day long. Some soaps have a tendency to leave your skin feeling oily after use, but you won’t run into any such issues here.

We also love the larger size of Henry Cavendish’s offering here. The size of the soap should last anywhere from 3 to 6 months depending on how frequently you use it, and after microwaving the stuff for just about 20 seconds or so, it can fit into any standard-size shaving mug that you own or are thinking about buying.

2. Proraso Shaving Soap

Proraso’s Shaving Soap is a bit more affordable than what you’ll find with Henry Cavendish, but don’t let the lower price make you think that this is a lesser quality product. Proraso is one of the most premium names when it comes to shaving soap, and that expertise is on full-display with this particular product.

There have been a ton of different soaps kicked out by Proraso over the years, but our favorite part of this specific one has to do with the eucalyptus oil. This helps to purify your skin while cleaning up your face, and the addition of menthol also kicks out an extremely soothing and calming cooling sensation that will make your skin feel fresh and clean beyond belief.

Proraso is best known for its extra creamy and dense lather, and while some guys prefer a lighter lather with their soap, the dense nature of Proraso’s helps to reduce any possible nicks and cuts even more. Over 95% of all the ingredients in this soap are all-natural, and you won’t find any artificial colors, animal ingredients, or mineral oils.


Some owners of Proraso’s shaving soap have complained about the tub it comes in not having a tight seal when shut, but if you find this to be an issue, you can always transfer the soap to the tub or bowl of your choice. Click here to view Proraso Shaving Soap


3. Tabac Original By Maurer & Wirtz For Men

Tabac shaving soap is a fan-favorite for a lot of readers of this site, and although it’s one of the pricier soaps on this list, it’s absolutely worth the price if you’re willing to spend a few extra dollars.


Lavender, citrus, and a host of other floral components are some of the main ingredients for the Tabac soap, and the aroma that this creates for is fresh, lively, and a bit fruity. Some guys will prefer the cooler and more subtle scent of what Proraso is offering, but if you want something with a bit more distinct of a smell, Tabac Original is for you.

Maurer & Wirtz have bee crafting shaving soaps and other men’s grooming products since as late as 1959, so it’s clear that the company knows a thing or two about what it takes to craft a soap that deserves to be used on your face. This isn’t the best choice for men that have sensitive skin, but if you want one of the best-smelling scents around, this is a shave soap that you absolutely need to check out.

4. Barrister and Mann Tallow Shaving Soap

After spending a good amount of time working on this guide, it came to our realization that a lot of guys are searching the Web for the “best tallow based shaving soap.” Tallow is a nice way to talk about fat that comes from mutton or beef, and while that may sound a bit gross upfront, it’s actually one of the best ingredients around for something such as a high-end shave soap.

Thanks to the tallow base of Barrister and Mann’s shaving soap, it’s extremely easy to create a super rich lather, and it offers the perfect amount of lubrication and cushion for both your face and razor when it comes time to clean up your facial hair. Even some of the best soaps around can often take a long time to whip up into a nice and useful lather, but the tallow ingredient means that you can start shaving in no time at all.

Along with tallow, some of the other best ingredients for the soap include bergamot, lemon, lavender, rosemary, and patchouli. Combine all of this with the fact that Barrister and Mann is made right here in the United States, and you’ve got a real winner on your hands. Click here to read more about Barrister and Mann Tallow Shaving Soap on Amazon.


5. The Blades Grim Gold Luxury Shaving Soap

The Blades Grim Gold Luxury Shaving Soap is the fifth and final soap on this list, and it’s one helluva product to end up. The Blades Grim has only been creating men’s shaving soap since 2014, but despite the company’s young age, it’s already proven to know what it takes to create an extremely wonderful soap and lather.


Blades Grim’s soap is handmade in the USA, and the company uses only all-natural ingredients to create for as pure of a shaving experience as possible. The best way to describe the scent is as having a subtle vanilla undertone that coexists with musky, smoky smells as well. That may sound a little odd right off the cuff, but trust us when we say that it’s one of the best-smelling shaving soaps we’ve ever had the pleasure of using.


Final Thoughts

The best smelling shave soap is a very subjective thing based on who you’re talking to, and while not everyone will agree that one soap smells better than the rest, the five products mentioned on this list are varied and different enough that you shouldn’t have any trouble finding the perfect one for you. And, no matter which soap you end up choosing, it’ll be a huge upgrade from the shaving cream or gel you’re currently using.